Books on nationalism
Nations and Nationalism since 1780
Programme, Myth, Reality
| Author | Eric J. Hobsbawm |
|---|---|
| First published | 1990 |
| Theme | Theories of nationalism |
Summary
Based on Eric Hobsbawm's Wiles Lectures, this concise history argues that nations do not make states and nationalisms — rather, nationalism and states make nations. Hobsbawm follows the idea of the nation from the age of revolutions, through the liberal "threshold principle" (only nations large enough to be viable deserved states), to the ethnic and linguistic nationalism of 1870–1918 and its apogee after 1918. He examines "proto-national" bonds such as language, religion and shared political experience, and closes with the provocative suggestion that nationalism was becoming less central to history.
Key ideas
- Nations are a recent invention, created by nationalism and states.
- Popular "proto-national" loyalties were reshaped from above.
- Nationalism changed from a liberal programme into an ethnic-linguistic one after 1870.
Why it matters
Together with Anderson and Gellner, it is one of the three foundational "modernist" accounts of the nation.
Background and context
Hobsbawm was one of the best-known British historians of the 20th century, a Marxist best remembered for his four "Age of" volumes on the modern world from 1789 to 1991. The lectures behind this book were delivered at Queen's University Belfast, a setting where questions of nation and state were far from academic. The book appeared in 1990, just as the collapse of communism in Eastern Europe was unleashing a new wave of national movements, and Hobsbawm addressed these events in a later edition. Readers have long debated his view that nationalism was in decline; the decades since have given critics plenty of material. Even so, his distinction between nationalism from above, pursued by states and elites, and the more ambiguous loyalties of ordinary people remains a central tool of analysis.
Who should read it
Read Nations and Nationalism since 1780 if you want a compact historical overview by a master historian, with a sceptical edge. It works best after a first theoretical introduction such as Anderson, and pairs naturally with The Invention of Tradition.
Related guides and terms
For background, see Nationalism explained, Nation vs. state, What is a nation state. Key terms: nation, nationalism, civic nationalism, ethnic nationalism.
More books on theories of nationalism
- Imagined Communities — Benedict Anderson
- The Invention of Tradition — Eric J. Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger (eds.)
- Nationalism — Elie Kedourie
- Notes on Nationalism — George Orwell