Books on nationalism
Twice a Stranger
The Mass Expulsions that Forged Modern Greece and Turkey
| Author | Bruce Clark |
|---|---|
| First published | 2006 |
| Theme | Greece, the Balkans and the Ottoman successor states |
Summary
Journalist Bruce Clark tells the story of the compulsory population exchange agreed at Lausanne in 1923, in which over a million Orthodox Christians left Anatolia for Greece and hundreds of thousands of Muslims moved from Greece to Turkey. Drawing on interviews with survivors and archival research, he shows how religion, not language, decided who was "Greek" or "Turkish", and how the exchange created two more homogeneous nation states.
Key ideas
- Religion was the criterion for national membership in the exchange.
- Forced migration was used as a tool of state-building.
- Refugees were often strangers in their new "homeland".
Why it matters
It shows the human cost of making the population fit the nation state.
Background and context
Clark is a journalist who has written for The Economist and has long experience of Greece and Turkey. The convention on the exchange of populations was signed at Lausanne in January 1923, months before the main peace treaty, after the defeat of the Greek army in Anatolia and the burning of Smyrna in 1922. A few groups were exempted, notably the Greek Orthodox of Istanbul and the Muslims of Western Thrace. The exchange was later cited as a model for solving ethnic conflict through "unmixing" populations, a precedent that critics regard as deeply troubling. Clark's use of personal testimony gives a human face to a process usually described in the language of diplomacy.
Who should read it
Read Twice a Stranger if you want a moving, accessible account of one of the 20th century's largest forced migrations, or want to understand modern Greek and Turkish identity. It suits general readers as well as students of migration and international relations.
Related guides and terms
For background, see History of the nation state, Nationalism explained, Nation vs. state. Key terms: self determination, irredentism, multinational state, ethnic nationalism.
More books on greece, the balkans and the ottoman successor states
- The Greek Revolution — Mark Mazower
- The Greek Revolution and the Violent Birth of Nationalism — Yanni Kotsonis
- When Democracy Died — Hans-Lukas Kieser
- Imagining the Balkans — Maria N. Todorova