Guide
The future of the nation state in a globalised world
Since the 1990s, commentators have predicted the end of the nation state. Yet it has proved remarkably resilient. Here are the main forces pressing on it — and the reasons it endures.
Pressures from above and below
- Economic globalisation. Global supply chains, capital flows and multinational corporations limit how far any single government can control its economy.
- Supranational institutions. The European Union pools sovereignty in areas such as trade and, for eurozone members, monetary policy. The WTO, international courts and treaties also constrain states.
- Global challenges. Climate change, pandemics and cyber threats cross borders and require cooperation.
- Technology. The internet, cryptocurrencies and global platforms operate across jurisdictions.
- Sub-state nationalism. Movements in places such as Scotland and Catalonia seek more autonomy or independence — paradoxically, usually to create new nation states.
Why the nation state endures
States remain the only actors that can raise taxes, field armies, issue passports and enforce laws at scale. Crises such as the 2008 financial crash and the COVID-19 pandemic showed citizens turning to national governments for rescue. National identity also remains a powerful source of meaning and solidarity, and recent years have seen a resurgence of nationalist politics in many countries.
Possible futures
Scholars outline several scenarios: a reinforced nation state reclaiming control over borders and economies; pooled sovereignty, with states cooperating ever more closely through regional blocs; and multi-level governance, where authority is shared between cities, regions, states and global bodies. The most likely outcome is a mix — a world in which the nation state is no longer the only actor, but remains the central one.
Frequently asked questions
- Is the nation state in decline?
Its autonomy is constrained by globalisation and international institutions, but it remains the primary unit of political organisation and has shown strong resilience in recent crises.
- Does the European Union replace the nation state?
No. EU member states pool sovereignty in certain areas but remain sovereign states; they can leave, as the United Kingdom did in 2020.
Further reading
- Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott
- When Democracy Died by Hans-Lukas Kieser
- The Invention of China by Bill Hayton
- Imagining the Balkans by Maria N. Todorova