Books on nationalism
The Invention of the Land of Israel
From Holy Land to Homeland
| Author | Shlomo Sand |
|---|---|
| First published | 2012 |
| Theme | Asia, Russia and the Middle East |
Summary
Israeli historian Shlomo Sand argues that the "Land of Israel" was for centuries a religious idea — a holy land — rather than a national homeland, and that its transformation into a national territory was the work of modern Zionism, influenced by European nationalism and by Christian Zionism. The book is deliberately provocative and has been widely contested.
Key ideas
- Religious attachment differs from national territorial claims.
- Zionism reshaped the meaning of the land.
- National homelands are historical constructions.
Why it matters
A controversial application of constructivist theory to one of the most contested national territories.
Background and context
Sand is a historian at Tel Aviv University and the author of The Invention of the Jewish People (2008), which aroused fierce controversy; this book continues that argument. His approach draws on the modernist theories of nationalism found elsewhere on this list, such as those of Anderson and Hobsbawm, and applies them to Zionism. Many historians and critics have strongly disputed his conclusions, arguing that he underestimates the continuity of Jewish attachment to the land. Because it is so contested, the book is best read as one side of a debate rather than as a settled account, ideally alongside works offering different interpretations.
Who should read it
Read The Invention of the Land of Israel if you want to see constructivist theories of nationalism applied to a highly contested case, and are prepared to weigh a provocative argument critically. It suits readers interested in Israel, Zionism and the theory of national homelands.
Related guides and terms
For background, see Nationalism explained, History of the nation state, Future of the nation state. Key terms: sovereignty, decolonisation, nationalism, stateless nation.
More books on asia, russia and the middle east
- Siam Mapped — Thongchai Winichakul
- The Invention of China — Bill Hayton
- The Hindi Public Sphere 1920–1940 — Francesca Orsini
- The Russian Idea — Nikolai Berdyaev